Oh–

[ Even though they'd been talking cats this whole time, she somehow hadn't been expecting a cat and dinner combo. The sincere surprise on her face lights up her eyes a little in a way they usually don't – and then it turns into a smile. ]

Trust you to hunt down something like this and keep it under wraps for so long. [ She reaches out to take his hand and gives it a little squeeze. ] Have you been inside by yourself yet?